Crumb Fairy Bakery Sweet Selections

Sweet Selections

24 Hours' Notice on all Orders

Custom cakes are available. See Weddings Page for a list of cake flavors, fillings, frostings, and add-ins.

Scroll down to see examples.

Call us for more details and let's talk cake!

Cakes

Pies & Tarts

Individual Treats

Party Bites

Banana Split Cake

Any day can feel like Sunday with this fun and festive cake. Treat yourself to chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla cake layered with fresh banana slices, chopped peanuts, vanilla buttercream, chocolate sauce, and of course a cherry on top!

Strawberry Cream Cake

Imagine yourself in a strawberry field with berry and cream delight. Three layers of strawberry cake, strawberry-cream-cheese filling, crispy strawberry pearls, and vanilla buttercream. Tastes just like a summer dream!

Princess Cake

three delicate layers of airy sponge cake, raspberry jam, and vanilla custard draped in our homemade marzipan

Straw Shortcake

Strawberry Shortcake in a cake: moist vanilla sponge cake, light and airy cream, white chocolate shavings and beautiful fresh strawberries

Berry Cloud Cake

three layers of vanilla sponge cake, sweetened whipped cream,
and TONS of fresh berries, garnished with white chocolate curls

Coconut Cake

three layers of vanilla sponge cake, coconut cream and sweet coconut shavings

Banana Coconut Cake

light vanilla sponge cake, banana custard, sweet coconut, and fresh banana slices

Carrot Cake

layered with smooth cream cheese frosting, crushed pineapple, shaved coconut, and toasted walnuts

Lemon Poppy Cake

lemon poppy cake, lemon curd, chantilly cream, and fresh blueberries

Pumpkin Spice Cake - seasonal

three layers of moist pumpkin cake with cream cheese frosting and candied pecans

Oreo Layer Cake

three layers of chocolate cake sandwich our sweet vanilla buttercream; crushed Oreos surround the cake and garnish the top

Elvis Cake

The king of cakes! Three layers of chocolate devil’s food cake, fresh bananas, and peanut-butter frosting make this a real rockin’ cake.

PB&J Cake

four layers of moist yellow cake, peanut butter frosting, raspberry jam and coarsely chopped nuts

Reese's Choc PB Cake

chocolate cake with peanut-butter frosting, freshly roasted peanuts, and mini peanut-butter cups right on top

Red Velvet Cake

alternating layers of red velvet cake and silky cream cheese frosting

Blue Velvet Cake

The Fairy's twist on the classic red: Why not have it blue instead? Surprise your guests with something new. When was the last time you had a cake that was blue?

Grasshopper Cake

light-green mint buttercream and dark devil’s food cake

Vintage Choc Cake

our take on the classic chocolate cake with chocolate frosting, garnished with chocolate curls

German Choc Cake

chocolate cake with coconut-and-roasted-pecan frosting

Black Forest Cake

chocolate cake flavored with cherry liqueur, layered with whipped cream, cherries, and chocolate shavings

Choc Straw Shortcake

devil’s food cake, light chocolate mousse, fresh strawberries, whipped cream, and dark chocolate curls

Choc Truffle Cake

rich Belgian chocolate mousse, silky chocolate ganache, homemade truffles, and chocolate feathers, dusted with gold flakes

B&W Mousse Cake

delicate layers of white and chocolate mousse rest on a thin layer of devil’s food cake, draped in chocolate ganache and chocolate curls

Hepburn Cake

A cake fit for Audrey at the track! This elegant black and white cake showcases rich devil’s food cake and alternating layers of vanilla and chocolate buttercream. White and dark crispy pearls give this cake a unique and satisfying texture and design.

Choc Cloud Cake

A Crumb Fairy original, featuring three layers of devil’s food cake, smooth chocolate mousse, crispy chocolate pearls and lightly sweetened chantilly cream. It's draped in chocolate ganache and garnished with chocolate sprinkles.

Tiramisu Cake

Our twist on the classic Italian dessert with all the familiar flavors of chocolate, espresso, lady fingers and a light cream filling. Enjoy la dolce vita!

Mocha Delight

Three layers of devil’s food cake and mocha buttercream, dripping with chocolate ganache and chocolate-covered espresso beans--the perfect pick-me-up!

Boston Cream Cake

Five thin layers of vanilla sponge cake, vanilla custard, and lightly sweetened whipped cream, draped with chocolate ganache and toasted almonds. This cake is wicked good!

Show More

Caramel Apple Crumble

hand-cut apples tossed in our signature homemade caramel fill a flaky tart shell; the whole is smothered in a crunchy crumble topping

Lattice Apple Pie

bursting with apples, this towering pie is flaky, moist, sweet and delicious

Pumpkin Pie - seasonal

a crisp tart shell is filled to the brim with pure pumpkin bliss and garnished with just a touch of whipped cream

Key Lime Pie

refreshing key lime curd resting in our signature graham cracker crust and topped with sweet whipped cream and toasted coconut shavings

French Apple Almond Tart

A perfect treat with just the right amount of sweetness: an almond butter tart topped with thin, elegant apple slices. Also available in an assortment of seasonal flavors such as Cherry, Fig, or Plum.

Fresh Fruit Tart

a crispy tart shell filled with rich vanilla custard and adorned with an array of fresh seasonal fruits and berries

Peach Blueberry (or Blackberry) Tart

this delicate tart features peaches and fresh blueberries (or blackberries) baked in a crisp, flaky shell

Not-So-Southern Pecan Tart

folks down South may not be too thrilled about us topping our pecan pie with TONS of chocolate chunks but we think you will

Chocolate Hazelnut Torte

an elegant tart filled with chocolate hazelnut mousse, toasted hazelnuts and Nutella spread

Show More

Signature Bread Pudding - $5.50 each

Made with buttery croissants and our secret milk bath, no wonder everyone is raving about these individually sized treats! Flavors include Chocolate Chunk, Apple Cinnamon, or Mixed Berries.

Dessert Jars - $5.50 each

A new twist on personal desserts! These nostalgic mason jars are filled to the brim with layers of cake, frosting, and yummy goodness. Twist the lid to savor a variety of flavors such as Red Velvet, Blue Velvet, Apple Caramel, Cheesecake, Oreo Mud Pie, S’mores, and more. They’re jarringly good!

Fairy Cupcakes - $3 each

You know we’ve got them! Flavors include Red or Blue Velvet, Black & White, Coconut, Chocolate Ganache, Peanut Butter & Jelly, Peanut Butter & Chocolate, Rocky Road, Boston Cream, Grasshopper, Vintage “Hostess,” Lemon Cream, Tiramisu, Carrot, and Black Forest.

Fairy Cookies - $1.75 each

moist and crunchy 3-inch cookies; flavors include Chocolate Truffle, Snickerdoodle, Oatmeal Cranberry, Chocolate Chunk, and Chocolate-Dipped Coconut Haystacks

Wicked Brownies - $2.50 to $3 each

fudgy not cakey, our brownies come topped with goodies like nuts, marshmallows, chocolate chips or just plain chocolate for the purists

Lemon Bars - $2.50 each

packing a serious lemon punch, these lemon bars are perfect for the citrus fanatic

Personal Pies - $4.50 each

flavors include Banana Cream, Berry, Coconut Cream, Chocolate Cream, Lemon Meringue, and Apple Crumble

French Macarons - $1.25 each

flavors include Double Chocolate, Tahitian Vanilla, Peanut Butter & Jelly, Chocolate Mint, Red Velvet, Raspberry Cream, Lemon, Chocolate Caramel Fleur de Sel, Mocha, Lavender, S’mores, Pistachio, Apricot and many more

Napoleons (Vanilla or Chocolate) $4

the classic French layered dessert—individually sized—that is both rich and flaky, light and satisfying in either Classic Vanilla or Silky Chocolate

Chocolate Truffle Domes - $4 ea

a personal, dome-shaped version of our decadent Truffle Cake

Chocolate Raspberry Mousse Cups $4

gorgeous marble chocolate cups filled with silky smooth chocolate mousse and fresh raspberries

Choc Caramel Apples -seasonal $5.50

crisp Granny Smiths drowned in caramel and covered in a variety of chocolates, nuts, chips and marshmallows

Individual Savory Quiches - $4.50 ea

flavors include Sun-Dried Tomato Basil, Bacon Cheddar, and Fennel Mushroom

Show More

Morning Pastries

Custom Cakes

Cake Pops - $1.75 each

Get vertical with balls of cake on a stick dipped in white or milk chocolate; flavors include Red or Blue Velvet, Chocolate, Vanilla, Lemon, Coconut, and Carrot

Choc Salted Caramel Tartlet - $2.50

Minimum order 1 dozen. These snappy chocolate cups are filled with our homemade salted caramel, rich chocolate ganache, and edible gold dust. Elegant and divine.

Mini Napoleons - $2 each

Minimum order one dozen. These adorable mini Napoleons come in either chocolate mousse or vanilla cream flavor. Our tiny take on the classic French pastry.

Trifle Shots - $2.75 each

Minimum order: 12 of each flavor. A perfectly layered dessert in small, no-mess, plexi shot glass. Flavors include Apple Caramel Cheesecake, Chocolate Mud Pie, Strawberry Shortcake, Red Velvet, and more!

Fairy Chocolate Shots - $2 each

tiny chocolate shot glasses filled with chili-infused chocolate milk, served with chocolate straws

Mini Tarts - $1.50 each

2-inch shells filled with a variety of flavors like Fresh Fruit, Key Lime, Lemon Meringue, Chocolate Hazelnut, White-Chocolate Passion Fruit, and Chocolate Mousse

Mini Éclairs - $1.75 each

2-inch versions of our elegant éclairs

Mini Cupcakes - $1.50 each

bite-sized versions of our Fairy Cupcakes in flavors like Red or Blue Velvet, Black & White, Coconut, Chocolate Ganache, Peanut Butter & Jelly, Peanut Butter & Chocolate, Rocky Road, Boston Cream, Grasshopper, Vintage “Hostess,” Lemon Cream, Tiramisu, Carrot, and Black Forest

Push-Ups - $3 each

A fun way to have your cake and eat it, too! ‘Vintage’ push-ups hold your layered cake so you can enjoy without a fork. Flavors include Red Velvet, Blue Velvet, Double Chocolate, Peanut-Butter Chocolate, Double Vanilla, Chocolate Mint, and Oreo.

Choc-Dipped Strawberries - seasonal

$2.25 each ~ colossal strawberries dipped in rich Belgian chocolate—white or dark

Show More

dino cupcakes

barnyard animals

Hello Kitty Cake

Dress cake

modern square cake

Micky and Minnie cakes

shark cake

monster truck cake

baby cake

Show More

Muffins - $2.75 ea

look forward to breakfast every morning with flavors like The Best Darn Blueberry Muffin Ever, Cranberry Orange, Lemon Poppy, Chocolate Chip, Pineapple Coconut, Honey Pecan Bran, and Banana Walnut

Scones - $2.50 ea

start your morning off right with our buttery, flaky scones; flavors include, Chocolate Hazelnut, Cranberry Orange, Apricot Ginger, and Mixed-Berry Lemon

Chocolate Cigar Twists - $2.25 each

made from Croissant dough and high-quality chocolate

Tree-Huggin' Granola - $6 per lb.

everything but the kitchen sink goes into our granola: walnuts, raisins, shredded coconut, almonds, pecans, dried cranberries and toasted oats

Cheese Danish - $3.25

morning pastry encased around Classic Cheese filling

Chocolate Danish - $3.25

morning pastry encased around Chocolate filling

Housemade Croissants - $3 to $3.75

we use the highest quality butter available; flavors include Plain Butter, Pan au Chocolat, and Twice-Baked Almond

Puff-Pastry Squares - $3 each

fresh puff pastry square mounded with your choice of Pear Almond, Apple Almond, or Mixed Berry compotes

Show More

Pies: 10-inch rounds, $35-$40; Tarts: 9-inch round (serves 8-10) $35-$40; 11-inch round (serves 12-15) $45-$50; 13-inch round (serves 15-18) $55-$60

1 dozen minimum; order 24 hours in advance or come by and see what's in the Sugar Nook case

1 dozen minimum; order 24 hours in advance

1 dozen minimum; order 24 hours in advance or come by and see what's in the Sugar Nook case

These are just some of the custom cakes we have done for our clients. Come on in and let's talk about your spectacular custom creation.

Cheesecakes

New York Cheesecake

creamy NYC-style cheesecake on a graham-cracker crust topped with cream-cheese frosting

Red Velvet Cheesecake

silky cheesecake stacked on top of our moist and delicious red velvet cake

Blue Velvet Cheesecake

silky cheesecake stacked on top of our moist and delicious blue velvet cake

Strawberry Cheesecake

New York cheesecake topped with fresh, ripe strawberries and lightly sweetened whipped cream--a quintessential combination.

Blueberry Cheesecake

New York cheesecake topped with fresh, ripe blueberries and lightly sweetened whipped cream. Only the freshest and sweetest blueberries make the cut for this bright and light dessert.

Pumpkin Cheesecake - seasonal

Topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream and a dusting of cinnamon, ours is somehow richer, creamier, and pumpkinier than all the others.

Caramel Apple Cheesecake

New York cheesecake topped with homey caramel apples and crunchy baked streusel

Lemon Cream Cheesecake

New York cheesecake with a layer of lemon curd, vanilla buttercream rosettes, and white chocolate shavings--tart and creamy

Rocky Road Cheesecake

fudgy brownie bites, toasted walnuts, mini marshmallows, caramel sauce, and chocolate ganache all top this satisfyingly sweet treat

Choc Cranberry Cheesecake - seasonal

deep, rich, chocolate cheesecake topped with our homemade cranberry compote and chocolate buttercream

Show More

11-inch rounds, $40 for the New York, $45 for the other flavors

mouse over all the images to see product names and descriptions